CatlouReviewed in the United States on January 30, 2025
5++ Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ THE THINGS WE LEAVE UNFINISHED will not be this story. This is one you will want to read from start to finish—and likely more than once. The present-day tale of Georgia and Noah captivates with its ups and downs and touches of angst and heartache. The bittersweet story of Scarlett and Jameson is sure to evoke strong emotions, especially heartbreak with many tears, but also moments of sweetness and joy.
What truly sets the narrative apart are the unexpected twists and turns that will leave you breathless; some may even provide a sense of peace to balance the sorrow. This is an incredible read that even now brings me to tears as I am writing this. The well-drawn characters and highly emotive writing will draw you in from the beginning and keep you thoroughly engaged until the very end.
The seamless transitions between the present and the past make it easier to navigate through the emotional challenges each character faces. Moreover, how it is written makes it even harder to put down, as you’ll be eager to find out what happens next for each couple. I can’t recommend this highly enough but be warned to keep plenty of tissues on hand, and if you read it before bed, you won’t be getting much sleep.
Amanda.bReviewed in the United States on February 12, 2025
The Things We Leave Unfinished by Rebecca Yarros is an emotional, dual-timeline romance blending historical and contemporary love stories. Heartfelt and beautifully written, it’s another great read like
Meredith MedinaReviewed in the United States on June 20, 2024
Wow. Just, wow.
So I went into this blind. I knew there was a divorce from the first few words in the synopsis I accidentally read, but that was literally all I knew.
I cannot remember the last time I cried so hard reading a book. It was such a beautiful, though heartbreaking, story. My review will in no way do this book justice, or adequately convey my feelings about it. I can’t seem to gather my thoughts cohesively, so this will be scattered. I have so much to say, but also don’t want to give any spoilers.
These characters stole my heart. Both men are truly swoon-worthy. While Noah’s previous “bachelor” ways are briefly (and more vaguely) mentioned, both men are gentlemen. The women show strength and intelligence. But all have moments of vulnerability.
This was my first Rebecca Yarros book, so maybe it’s how she typically writes, but, I loved the way the spicy scenes weren’t overtly explicit. They were still somehow very passionate.
There was a point in the book that I wasn’t loving the flashbacks, or rather the placement of them. They happen at such inopportune times. Just when I’m catching my stride and getting into the story, we go back in time. And the same happens in the past timeline. I get into it, and we jump into present again. I understand the reason for it stylistically, but it was still frustrating. That said, I realized about halfway through the reason it felt this way is because I loved all the characters so much. It wasn’t like one of those multi-POV books where I didn’t like this person and couldn’t wait to get back to someone else. I just genuinely was so invested in them all, in all the stories, that it was hard to break away once immersed.
The way the puzzle pieces come together kind of blew me away. In hindsight, it all made sense. Really, I enjoyed her writing style immensely.
PAST
At one point, my notes say “Is this a historical Romance?! I think I could love it.”
I love the romance of that era. Her modesty and morals. There’s just such a sweet innocence about it.
While a wartime romance isn’t for the faint of heart, I enjoyed the sense of urgency it created. The unknown of tomorrow. The way it matures a person, living through that.
I found myself wishing I understood more about the politics of the time (though admittedly that could very well be my own ignorance, and not that anything was missing from the book). And more of the particulars of what Scarlett and Constance were doing in the WAAF.
PRESENT
Georgia and Noah’s banter was fun. The care he shows her throughout the book is next level. He sits her down and reverses roles. He makes her tea. He explains how he won’t let her fall if she climbs.
Josefina CaperaReviewed in the United States on January 8, 2025
Rebecca Yarros has delivered a masterpiece that seamlessly blends historical romance with a contemporary twist, creating an emotional rollercoaster that will stay with readers long after the final page.
The dual love stories—Jameson and Scarlett during World War II and Noah and Georgia in the present—are beautifully crafted, with each narrative intertwining in a way that feels both natural and profoundly moving. The love between Jameson and Scarlett is timeless and heartbreaking, while Noah and Georgia's relationship offers hope and healing.
Yarros’ ability to weave these two storylines together is nothing short of brilliant. The contrast and connection between past and present add depth, making this more than just a love story; it’s a tale of resilience, sacrifice, and the enduring power of love.
This book is an absolute gem, earning a well-deserved ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) rating. If you’re a fan of historical romance with an emotional edge, this is a must-read!
christineReviewed in the United States on January 13, 2025
Absolutely the best book of 2025!!! Well developed characters that are realistic, loyal and unique bond of family. This was a gripping love story that spans generations. Nothing is given away until the ending the secret a sister kept and a love that lasted. Enjoy.
Amazon CustomerReviewed in the United States on February 7, 2025
Enjoyed the many characters and going back in time. Didn’t see the little twist coming until it happened. Quick, easy read.
Kindle CustomerReviewed in the United States on February 6, 2025
Such a beautiful, heartbreaking and different story. With twists and surprises, it was such a good read, made me cry at times, filled me with joy other times and although I suspected the ending, it still made me cry. I definitely recomend!
Panda BradyReviewed in the United States on February 8, 2025
Beautiful, tragic love story, don’t recommend reading where you don’t want to be seen crying. Great characters. Great story. Just read it
SCRReviewed in Mexico on January 7, 2025
Desde que empecé a leerlo me engancho, es un libro que habla mucho del amor, del amor de pareja, del amor de familia. Me encantó estar leyendo dos historias de épocas muy distintas al mismo tiempo, y ver la diferencia del amor en cada una. Lo recomiendo muchísimo
confuso e chatoReviewed in Brazil on January 3, 2025
Georgia e Noah, Scarlley e Jameson.
Vale a leitura.
Livro delicioso e leitura fluida e história gostosa, que vc fica querendo saber o final.
Amazon CustomerReviewed in Canada on October 28, 2024
I love, loved it! Intricately detailed and beautifully portrayed, with such intense emotion. The plot is seamless. A must read!
Wandaka LyngdohReviewed in India on January 11, 2025
Have you ever read a book so beautiful and powerful that you’ve been reluctant to put your feelings about it into words, only to find that, over time, you’ve forgotten many of the emotions you wanted to express? That’s exactly what happened to me with this book.
I picked it up without knowing it would become one of my favorite reads from last year. The letters in this story were both heartwarming and heartbreaking, and the chemistry and emotional tension in both love stories were intense. Though I anticipated certain parts of the ending, I couldn’t help but wish for things to turn out well for everyone. This book made me feel as if I were mourning the loss of a real person—it made me cry, laugh, shatter my heart, and ultimately heal it.
Each love story was written with such beauty, and I’m so grateful that some characters found the happy ending they deserved. The way the struggles, pain and separation caused by wars were conveyed made me feel everything the characters were experiencing. Even now, my heart still aches when I think of how it ended for some, and my mind is still tangled in the emotions, but if I could give this book a million stars, I would.
Martina HartmannReviewed in Germany on December 29, 2024
CatlouReviewed in the United States on January 30, 2025
5++ Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ THE THINGS WE LEAVE UNFINISHED will not be this story. This is one you will want to read from start to finish—and likely more than once. The present-day tale of Georgia and Noah captivates with its ups and downs and touches of angst and heartache. The bittersweet story of Scarlett and Jameson is sure to evoke strong emotions, especially heartbreak with many tears, but also moments of sweetness and joy. What truly sets the narrative apart are the unexpected twists and turns that will leave you breathless; some may even provide a sense of peace to balance the sorrow. This is an incredible read that even now brings me to tears as I am writing this. The well-drawn characters and highly emotive writing will draw you in from the beginning and keep you thoroughly engaged until the very end. The seamless transitions between the present and the past make it easier to navigate through the emotional challenges each character faces. Moreover, how it is written makes it even harder to put down, as you’ll be eager to find out what happens next for each couple. I can’t recommend this highly enough but be warned to keep plenty of tissues on hand, and if you read it before bed, you won’t be getting much sleep.
Amanda.bReviewed in the United States on February 12, 2025
The Things We Leave Unfinished by Rebecca Yarros is an emotional, dual-timeline romance blending historical and contemporary love stories. Heartfelt and beautifully written, it’s another great read like
Meredith MedinaReviewed in the United States on June 20, 2024
Wow. Just, wow. So I went into this blind. I knew there was a divorce from the first few words in the synopsis I accidentally read, but that was literally all I knew. I cannot remember the last time I cried so hard reading a book. It was such a beautiful, though heartbreaking, story. My review will in no way do this book justice, or adequately convey my feelings about it. I can’t seem to gather my thoughts cohesively, so this will be scattered. I have so much to say, but also don’t want to give any spoilers. These characters stole my heart. Both men are truly swoon-worthy. While Noah’s previous “bachelor” ways are briefly (and more vaguely) mentioned, both men are gentlemen. The women show strength and intelligence. But all have moments of vulnerability. This was my first Rebecca Yarros book, so maybe it’s how she typically writes, but, I loved the way the spicy scenes weren’t overtly explicit. They were still somehow very passionate. There was a point in the book that I wasn’t loving the flashbacks, or rather the placement of them. They happen at such inopportune times. Just when I’m catching my stride and getting into the story, we go back in time. And the same happens in the past timeline. I get into it, and we jump into present again. I understand the reason for it stylistically, but it was still frustrating. That said, I realized about halfway through the reason it felt this way is because I loved all the characters so much. It wasn’t like one of those multi-POV books where I didn’t like this person and couldn’t wait to get back to someone else. I just genuinely was so invested in them all, in all the stories, that it was hard to break away once immersed. The way the puzzle pieces come together kind of blew me away. In hindsight, it all made sense. Really, I enjoyed her writing style immensely. PAST At one point, my notes say “Is this a historical Romance?! I think I could love it.” I love the romance of that era. Her modesty and morals. There’s just such a sweet innocence about it. While a wartime romance isn’t for the faint of heart, I enjoyed the sense of urgency it created. The unknown of tomorrow. The way it matures a person, living through that. I found myself wishing I understood more about the politics of the time (though admittedly that could very well be my own ignorance, and not that anything was missing from the book). And more of the particulars of what Scarlett and Constance were doing in the WAAF. PRESENT Georgia and Noah’s banter was fun. The care he shows her throughout the book is next level. He sits her down and reverses roles. He makes her tea. He explains how he won’t let her fall if she climbs.
Josefina CaperaReviewed in the United States on January 8, 2025
Rebecca Yarros has delivered a masterpiece that seamlessly blends historical romance with a contemporary twist, creating an emotional rollercoaster that will stay with readers long after the final page. The dual love stories—Jameson and Scarlett during World War II and Noah and Georgia in the present—are beautifully crafted, with each narrative intertwining in a way that feels both natural and profoundly moving. The love between Jameson and Scarlett is timeless and heartbreaking, while Noah and Georgia's relationship offers hope and healing. Yarros’ ability to weave these two storylines together is nothing short of brilliant. The contrast and connection between past and present add depth, making this more than just a love story; it’s a tale of resilience, sacrifice, and the enduring power of love. This book is an absolute gem, earning a well-deserved ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) rating. If you’re a fan of historical romance with an emotional edge, this is a must-read!
christineReviewed in the United States on January 13, 2025
Absolutely the best book of 2025!!! Well developed characters that are realistic, loyal and unique bond of family. This was a gripping love story that spans generations. Nothing is given away until the ending the secret a sister kept and a love that lasted. Enjoy.
Amazon CustomerReviewed in the United States on February 7, 2025
Enjoyed the many characters and going back in time. Didn’t see the little twist coming until it happened. Quick, easy read.
Kindle CustomerReviewed in the United States on February 6, 2025
Such a beautiful, heartbreaking and different story. With twists and surprises, it was such a good read, made me cry at times, filled me with joy other times and although I suspected the ending, it still made me cry. I definitely recomend!
Panda BradyReviewed in the United States on February 8, 2025
Beautiful, tragic love story, don’t recommend reading where you don’t want to be seen crying. Great characters. Great story. Just read it
SCRReviewed in Mexico on January 7, 2025
Desde que empecé a leerlo me engancho, es un libro que habla mucho del amor, del amor de pareja, del amor de familia. Me encantó estar leyendo dos historias de épocas muy distintas al mismo tiempo, y ver la diferencia del amor en cada una. Lo recomiendo muchísimo
confuso e chatoReviewed in Brazil on January 3, 2025
Georgia e Noah, Scarlley e Jameson. Vale a leitura. Livro delicioso e leitura fluida e história gostosa, que vc fica querendo saber o final.
Amazon CustomerReviewed in Canada on October 28, 2024
I love, loved it! Intricately detailed and beautifully portrayed, with such intense emotion. The plot is seamless. A must read!
Wandaka LyngdohReviewed in India on January 11, 2025
Have you ever read a book so beautiful and powerful that you’ve been reluctant to put your feelings about it into words, only to find that, over time, you’ve forgotten many of the emotions you wanted to express? That’s exactly what happened to me with this book. I picked it up without knowing it would become one of my favorite reads from last year. The letters in this story were both heartwarming and heartbreaking, and the chemistry and emotional tension in both love stories were intense. Though I anticipated certain parts of the ending, I couldn’t help but wish for things to turn out well for everyone. This book made me feel as if I were mourning the loss of a real person—it made me cry, laugh, shatter my heart, and ultimately heal it. Each love story was written with such beauty, and I’m so grateful that some characters found the happy ending they deserved. The way the struggles, pain and separation caused by wars were conveyed made me feel everything the characters were experiencing. Even now, my heart still aches when I think of how it ended for some, and my mind is still tangled in the emotions, but if I could give this book a million stars, I would.
Martina HartmannReviewed in Germany on December 29, 2024
Alles bestens